Free K-5 printables
Skip to content

Would you rather · Grades 3-5

24 Would you rather questions for 3rd to 5th Grade

Bigger questions that make 3rd to 5th graders give reasons, ideal for debates and opinion writing. All 24 questions are below, and the printable has them as cards plus an opinion writing page.

  1. 1. Would you rather...

    Abe able to read mindsBbe able to see the future

  2. 2. Would you rather...

    Atravel 100 years into the pastBtravel 100 years into the future

  3. 3. Would you rather...

    Anever have to sleepBnever have to eat

  4. 4. Would you rather...

    Agive up screens for a monthBgive up sweets for a month

  5. 5. Would you rather...

    Abe famousBbe the smartest person in the world

  6. 6. Would you rather...

    Abe able to stop timeBbe able to rewind time

  7. 7. Would you rather...

    Aexplore the deep oceanBexplore outer space

  8. 8. Would you rather...

    Ahave lots of good friendsBhave one best friend

  9. 9. Would you rather...

    Abe great at one thingBbe good at everything

  10. 10. Would you rather...

    Alive where it is always summerBlive where it is always winter

  11. 11. Would you rather...

    Ainvent something that helps peopleBdiscover a new animal

  12. 12. Would you rather...

    Aalways know the right answerBalways ask the best questions

  13. 13. Would you rather...

    Alive in a small house near friendsBlive in a big house far away

  14. 14. Would you rather...

    Anever make a mistakeBlearn something from every mistake

  15. 15. Would you rather...

    Abe an inventorBbe an explorer

  16. 16. Would you rather...

    Ahave a robot that does your choresBhave a robot that does your homework

  17. 17. Would you rather...

    Alead the teamBbe a star player on the team

  18. 18. Would you rather...

    Aspeak every languageBbe great at every sport

  19. 19. Would you rather...

    Avisit every countryBvisit every planet

  20. 20. Would you rather...

    Awork on your ownBwork in a group

  21. 21. Would you rather...

    Abe the oldest childBbe the youngest child

  22. 22. Would you rather...

    Aget $100 to keepBget $1,000 to give away

  23. 23. Would you rather...

    Aprotect the rainforestsBprotect the oceans

  24. 24. Would you rather...

    Aknow how everything worksBknow why everything happens

Would you rather: think deeper: printable question cardsWould you rather opinion writing page with sentence starters

More would you rather questions

Common questions

What is in the printable?

24 question cards, eight to a page, each with an A choice and a B choice, then an opinion writing page with sentence starters (4 pages in all).

What grade are these questions for?

Grades 3-5. Bigger questions that make 3rd to 5th graders give reasons, ideal for debates and opinion writing.

More brain games

All would you rather questions